Saturday, 12 December 2009

Briefing for the meeting with Gary Locke (by Ning Wang)

12 Chinese and American Youth have gathered at the "secret room" in the upper corner of Bella Center this afternoon to have a conversation with the United States secretariat of Commerce Mr. Gary Locke. Though having Chinese origin, Mr. Locke showed critical opinion upon Chinese Climate Policy. He insisted that "China should take more responsibility in carbon emission. In the future history textbook, China should take more responsibility in regardless of population if the climate change really occur." The representatives from China Youth COP15 delegation team can hardly agree with Mr. Locke's view. "Common but differentiate principle" should be followed at any time. China, as the leader of developing countries, should have the opportunity to coordinate their own development and emission reduction. The emission reduction obligation for those developed countries is a kind of responsibility and compensation for their exploitation of environment during industrialization not a kind of charitable donation. We are sort of disappointed with the attitude of US official, we do hope more effective progress could be made in next week's negotiation.

"Made in Denmark" better at delivering green message (By Si TingTing)

When it comes to attracting people to the overheated topic of climate change, it's never bad to go dramatic.

The first few days of the Copenhagen climate summit passed with an awful lot of speeches. All negotiators said that their countries are committed to do more to get a climate deal. A handful of others made emotional pleas that the poor are suffering from climate disasters. But none of them work better to wake up people's numbed senses than a presentation of efficiency-minded ideas, especially when the ideas are of Danish origin.

The made-in-Denmark conference itself is pretty green by all itself: no bottled water, no gifts of Little Mermaid statuettes for the delegates.

The traditional Christmas tree in Copenhagen's Town Hall square, like the Rockefeller Center Christmas Tree in New York, will only remain lit as long as enough energy is being generated by the 15 bikes set up to power them. The 21-meter-tall tree is decorated with 700 energy-efficient bulbs and the alternative means of powering the Christmas lighting will save the environment nine tons of carbon dioxide.

Next to Copenhagen's landmark Little Mermaid statue, local sculptor Jens Galschiot set up a provocative statue showing an obese Lady Justice sitting on an emaciated African man, representing hypocrisy in the climate debate.

The message to reduce environmental impact went so deep into Danish people's lifestyle that they even look to people's final journey for emission cuts. Starting in 2011, new environmental regulations in Denmark will require all crematoriums to have mercury filters. There are also plans to replace seven crematoriums in eastern Denmark with a single central facility for the sake of energy efficiency.

However, it's not just the Danish who are good at delivering the "go green" message; so are those who came to Denmark.

Scottish businesses and non-governmental organizations created a special-edition Scotch whisky as a gift to key negotiators at the talks. The 42 percent proof (21 percent alcohol), 20-year-old spirit is called TwentyTwenty 42 -- to mark Scotland's pledge to cut its greenhouse gases by 42 percent by 2020.

British wildlife sculptor Mark Coreth brought a life-sized ice polar bear to downtown Copenhagen to let people touch the bear and feel what their touches could do to hasten its watery demise. He hopes that people will appreciate the effects of human action and the plight of the polar bear. Coreth is now back in London to carve a twin bear to display in London's Trafalgar Square and hopes to follow with others around the world, even Tian'anmen Square in Beijing.

In addition, youth delegates from around the world are using their own low-budget but novel ways to pressure the negotiators. Yesterday, outside the main plenary session conference room and against a backdrop of suits and briefcases, scores of youth from around the world, dressed in pajamas and armed with pillows, asked their leaders to deliver a deal which will ensure the survival of all human beings and species. And today, a Chinese youth dressed as a traditional Chinese doctor will send out his prescription for a healthy earth at the conference center.

Friday, 11 December 2009

“Less than 2 US Dollars of fast aid on average is not even enough for buying a coffin..." (by Scully Meng)


“Less than 2 US Dollars of fast aid on average is not even enough for buying a coffin..."


Deputy Chief Negotiator Su Wei said, the price level at Copenhagen is really high, a fast track of 10billion US dollars shared by the world pupulation will end up to be 2 dollars per person, not even enough to buy a cup of coffee here. A foreign colleague has interpreted as "coffin" though...

On the sencond day of COP15, Su Wei has criticised the EU, US, Japan and the major developed countries during the media briefing.

"The EU should not always compare to China. They should compare to the figure they have committed to in KP for the first commitment period." Said Su Wei, when talking about EU's query regarding China's reduction figure.

Considering the historical GHG emission of developed countries in the past 200 years of industrialisation process, China considers the reduction commitment of EU, US, Japan and other major developed countries in their second commitment period still lower than expectation. Su Wei has given the reporters relevant figures: EU's target of 20% reduction on the 1990 level is equivalent to an annual reduction of 1.05%. This is less than a half of their 2.48% average annual reduction target in their first commitment period. Even if the commitment increases to 30%, this is still only equivalent to an annual reduction of 1.93%. In the face of the self-claimed "ambitious" targets, EU is still comparing its own duties to China's voluntary reduction actions, Su Wei says, "EU is not kind at all".

Regarding Japan's 25% reduction target based on 1990 level, Su Wei thinks that there are still concerns despite the progress. Firstly, one of the conditoins associated with Japan's commitment is a reduction commitment by China, and KP states that developing countries do not have reduction obligations, therefore the requirement of Japan has violated KP. Secondly Japan has required the US to join KP, this is an impossible condition, therefore Japan's target does not need to be commited to given the conditions not realised. Even if eventually the conditions are fulfilled and Japan has commited, Su Wei still casts doubts on the figures: Japan is very likely to achieve its target by a substantial purchase of carbon credit or increase in carbon-sink program, instead of solid carbon reduction actions.

"At the current moment, the commitment of the US will determine the final outcome of COP15," Su Wei said, but the reduction of 17% based on 2005 level of the US is hardly a substantial reduction target, same as the EU. In fact, the CO2 emission of the US from 1990 to 2005 has grown substantially, to 16%, therefore the current commitment is only a 1% reduction at 1990 level.

Regarding another important issue, financing, Su Wei said, even if the finance provided by "fast track" of 10billion US dollars by 2012 has a large total sum, it is hard to help the developing countires with an enormous population. "If we share the money with everyone in the world, we get less than 2 US dollars per person, this is not even enough to buy a cup of coffee in Cophenhagen." Su Wei told the reporter.

Su Wei has always emphasised the truth of China being a developing country. The current mission of developing countries are still economic development, poverty elimination, achieving sustainable developement, whilst the developed countries has the capability and historical responsibility to pioneer in taking reduction actions. If they abandon KP and Bali Action Plan whilst push developing countries for reduction commitments, this is definitely not a positive signal for global action in fighting climate change.

A snapshot in Chinese policy towards COP-15 (by Ning Wang)


As Tuvalu threw a tough question to the parties, China delegation used their own words to demonstrate their great achievement and potential contribution to the current and future climate mitigation.

Prof. Jiankun He, is the former executive vice president of the country wide renowned talent pool-Tsinghua University, and now works as the director of Tsinghua low carbon economy institute. He has provided consultancy for China government on energy and climate change issues for past decade.

To emphasis of China’s past contribution to world climate, He reminded developed countries should move their focal point from total CO2 emission increase to energy intensity (energy consumption per unit GDP, in tce/yuan) decrease. China enjoyed a significantly low energy intensity of 2% from 2000 to 2005, while the number stayed as high as 23% (1960~1974) and 45% (1971~1997) in Japan and South Korea during heavy chemical-driven industrialization.

Trillions of money has been put on to improve China’s industrial energy efficiency. Achievements are significant either. 750 million tons of CO2 emission was eliminated by closing down small thermal power station. The total power generation capacity supposed to be 100 thousand KW which equals to 70% of Great Britain total power demand. This project will extend its border to small cement production unit and steel plant. Extra cost of 1 million employment caused by shutting down industrial plants will occur to central government. Public economic policies endow special priority to renewable energy sectors—600 yuan/kw and 20,000 yuan/kw subsidy is designated to wind power sector and photovoltaic solar energy sector respectively.

Other neutral source of information indicates China’s ambition to mitigate climate change even though “irrational” investment was made by the government. HSBC claimed China rank number two world widely in “Green investment” right following South Korea. Mckinsey also insisted the government will have to endure 1.5 trillion Yuan forgone investment in eleven five years plan, and the number was estimated to be 1.9~3.5 trillion Yuan.

To reveal developed world’s insincerity, He’s number for US and EU applying same evaluating method with China was 32% and 30~40% respectively.

China negotiator also presented a perfect argument on Chinese attitude toward ongoing climate talk when facing foreign media’s challenging. Ambassador Yu Qingtai answered 6 questions on today’s new releasing. To make it in a concise way, three major points should be enough.

Historical emission gap between developed countries and developing countries should be the major responsibility of those rich countries to reduce emission even restricts their economic development. “The money from developed countries is not a donation but a demonstration of their responsibility and compensation to make up for their priority to economic development.” Ambassador Yu firmly declared it.

From the Chinese youth angle, we do appreciate the ambitious target Chinese government made. Some serious facts about China’s forgone cost to promote the clean energy revolution are really astonishing. However, we know the progress in the following 8 days is for both parties to make compromise from their baseline towards a common agreement. In my point of view, Danish text and Beijing draft are intentionally released by both parties as a stimulus to the solid negotiation. Significant result is expected to get in next couple of days. Here is a brief introduction to next article-“Sino-US on fire”.

2009-12-09 | The COP 15 Intergenerational Commitment Book

Growing Together in a Changing Climate:

The COP 15 Intergenerational Commitment Book

Background

Since September 2008, the UNFCCC secretariat has liaised with youth organizations around the world in an effort to facilitate participation of young people in the UNFCCC process. A year later, the secretariat granted preliminary constituency status to the youth, now recognized as the YOUNGO constituency.

With the financial support of the Government of the Netherlands and input from YOUNGO, the secretariat has designed and planned a series of events to support and enhance the COP preparatory activities of the youth, increase youth participation from developing countries and support and enhance the youth contribution to COP 15.

In the heart of the “Youth Arcade,” comprised of 15 youth-related booths, the secretariat will host a UNFCCC Youth booth, where participating United Nations agencies and youth organisations will present their initiatives on climate change and youth. This will be a place for all actors to display their success stories, identify synergies and develop new partnerships. All events taking place at the booth will be included in a daily programme of events prepared and distributed by the secretariat. This programme at the booth will be promoted through the COP 15 daily programme, as well as the daily programme of the Youth Arcade.

Concept

The booth will also host a new initiative called the COP 15 Intergenerational Commitment Book (the Book), where Parties, United Nations agencies, intergovernmental and non-governmental organizations and the private sector will be invited to express their views on and commitments to improving the youth participation in addressing climate change. The Book will be officially launched at the Intergenerational Inquiry Side Event on 10 December, where speakers will be invited to sign it. Speakers at the youth briefings organized by the secretariat will also be invited to sign the Book.

At the end of COP 15, the Book will be presented and handed over to the Mexican Government and host of COP 16, possibly at the last briefing with the Mexican Minister.

Entries in the book will be recorded in a database and a report of initiatives and commitments will be produced and circulated through CC:iNet, the UNFCCC information network clearing house. At COP 16, the Intergenerational Side Event will be the forum to, inter alia, share the results of the initiative and launch the COP 16 Book.

Implementation Plan

8 December: Presented to LCA and KP chairs at their youth briefing

10 December: Official Launch at the Intergenerational Inquiry and promotion in the official daily programme

10-18 December: UNFCCC Youth Booth and Youth Briefings

18 December:` Hand over to Mexican Government

January - December 2010: Monitoring of commitments by YOUNGO

COP 16`: Intergenerational Side Event (Share results and launched COP 16 Book).

Actions:

Action

Person in charge

Timeline

Promote initiative amongst Parties, United Nations agencies, intergovernmental and non-governmental organizations and the private sector.

Brankica - Adriana - Laurence

10 - 18 December

Process entries in database

Brankica - Adriana

10 - 18 December

Liaise with the media for VIP visits

Adriana

10 - 18 December

Presentation of the Book at the Side Event

Laurence

10 December

Presentation of the Book at mini-events at the booth

Adriana

TBC

Create a report of the initiative

YOUNGO

TBD

Upload the report to CC:iNet

David

Share results of the initiative

Laurence

COP 16

Wednesday, 9 December 2009

COP15 Day 3 - CCS and CDM

I have to say what I gathered these days are rather miscellaneous, just the way things are presented here at the conference. UN has planetary sessions of meetings open to all participants every day. People can even just sit on the side floors, and take photos whever you want, as long as you don’t disturb others and go to podium to disrupt the chair of the session… It was in effect very hard to follow exactly as the things they discussed are rather technical and often follow-ups/sum-ups of previous discussions during earlier various talks. One thing that I was present and was actually able to understand well was about if carbon capturing and sequestration (CCS) should be included under the Clean Development Mechanism (CDM).

Most developing countries [I have the recording that I can trace back exactly which countries said so, but not now] expressed the concerns over CCS as an immature and rather controversial technology to be added. CCS is basically the capturing of CO2 from burning of fossil fuels before it emits into the atmosphere, and storing it underground or sell for other purposes, such as injecting into your soda or to get more oil out of the field (tar sand as well I think). There are concerns about the instability of the injection at underground level and the long-term leakage of it from the ground. Several developed countries (e.g. Sweden and Australia) advocated for its enlistment as they have enough data to support the feasibility of such technology. Kuwait, interestingly, cried for serious consideration of the technology, as they’ve studies to prove its feasibility; they have none CDM projects and CCS is their one shot, blah blah blah (Okay, you can see I am strongly biased..). they requested the floor four times during the discussion to restate and accentuate their strong adaptation. I was not really buying their saying first for reasons stated above. And second, think about the Kuwait as a major oil-fed country, how much more oil and more coal they can burn with CCS?

Yet I still think it is a complicated issue, considering the possibility of getting funding for developing countries to either build new coal-fired plants with CCS or retrofitting old ones (less technologically feasible). It is a good thing if something could be done to mitigate the climate change effect of the coal burning but it is absolutely not a radical solution and even giving excuse to continue using coal. Coal addicts and many more, just feel it is stupid not to use up the reserves. Yet in a longer term it will affect the development of renewable energies for sure. As long as there are “alternative” options such as coal, there is less incentives to have the renewable, which are more like the common sense to me.

The Traditional Chinese Medicine diagnosis on climate change in the Bella Centre

This is the second major event organised by the China Youth COP15 after the start of the COP15.

Today we had a major campaigning event in the Bella Centre, the traditional Chinese Medicine diagnoses on climate change. Our inspiration came from the philosophy behind Chinese medicine - the diagnosis of a whole body as a system, so that if there is a syptom arisen from one particular area, there must be underlying causes and problems of the whole system which have fundamentally caused it. We want to view the whole world as one system, and work together to combat climate change. If only one nation goes forward, it cannot achieve much without cooperation from others.

Also that Chinese medicine is a long-term cure that it promotes the enhancement of overall wellness rather than a quick fix. We have to admit that a quick fix will not work for climate change mitigation and we have to rehabilitate the Earth from within - a fundamental systematic change is needed.

So today, we, the China Youth Delegation, have set up a stand outside Bella center decorated as
the traditional Chinese Medicine doctor stand. Meanwhile, we have designed a two
meters high thermometer. At every hour, the temperature was raised one degree
Celsius, and one living creature (we had our team members dressed up as pandas, monkeys, elephants etc. ) perish and be taken always by the devil.

In the picture below, our team member is holding a picture of a bird species that has almost reached extinction as a consequence of climate change.

We encouraged as many delegates to participate as possible and we have given out a diagnosed prescription which addresses issues and actions regarding climate change to each 'patient'.

Each 'patient' has given their commitment to climate action and signed our book of commitment after having their diagnosis. We have designed the event so that the more people coming to participate, the slower the growth of the temperature on the thermometer.

We sincerely hope that this event can be thought-provoking for our participants. They might leave and lose the diagnosed prescription paper, but we hope that they can remember this unique event organised by the Chinese youths and take actions NOW before it is too late.